pgc all green working and signpost with lettering new colour 2
pgc all green working and signpost with lettering new colour 2
facebook icon twitter icon

Forum topic: Broomfield House - latest news

Broomfield House - latest news

Colin Younger

28 Aug 2016 23:24 #2255

Share share on facebook icon share on twitter icon Share by email

...

broomfield house thumbnailEnfield Council has just posted on its website a comprehensive set of documents prepared for the Broomfield House Partnership Boards’ [1] consideration of the future of the House [2] and Stableyard. These can be read as they stand, but in order to better understand these papers, it might be helpful to summarise how we got here.

broomfield house conservation management plan coverAs well as the House, the Conservation Management Plan considers the Stables and the Park as a wholeRecent Plans

A number of earlier plans proposed by Enfield and/or community groups have for one reason or another not succeeded. The most recent plan was the 2012 joint Council-Broomfield House Trust/Friends of Broomfield Park working group bid to the Heritage Lottery Fund (HLF) for the rebuilding of the House. Regrettably, the HLF told us in 2013 that were unable to agree to provide the almost £5m bid on a basis that this was a traditional Heritage project, which was risky given the extent of the damage and, in practice, was not in their view of national significance warranting a £5m grant.

Heritage Enterprise Programme

Given this, Enfield Council in conjunction with Historic England and the HLF determined that an approach to the HLF under its relatively new Heritage Enterprise Programme should be explored for both the House and stableyard (an almost equal priority for the Trust). Any scheme to rebuild and reopen Broomfield House would have to raise the capital costs and cover future running costs. The Enterprise Programme is designed for properties such as Broomfield House where traditional heritage fund raising has not succeeded, and under which enabling commercial involvement has to be secured before the HLF bid is made. Commercial involvement in such a heritage property would normally be unacceptable in planning terms, but for the fact that it brings sufficient public benefits which could not otherwise be achieved. The key element is usually securing the long-term future of the asset. The HLF contribution is intended to cover what is described as the “conservation deficit”, which is defined as the amount by which the cost of repair exceeds its market value on completion.

This latest approach starts with the creation of a Conservation Management Plan (CMP). This is the key step recommended by Historic England.

The purpose of the CMP is to provide a comprehensive and holistic assessment of the significance of the House, Stables and Park in order to provide information on the relative value or significance of the component parts of the heritage assets. It is intended to provide the basis of a long term maintenance and management strategy for the Park. It is possible that in the future a bid for funds to improve the Park and restore the baroque water gardens might be made under the Parks for People programme.

The second element is composed of the various Options Appraisal reports, intended to develop alternative viable future uses of the House and Stable Block.

The Long List Options

The Long List Options Appraisal draws on the CMP, on the outcome of the public consultation which ran to November 2015, on the Market analysis and on the Options Appraisal (see below). It considers and evaluates a wide variety of options, concluding that the best fit is that of an arts-based community use. This could involve artist studio and workshop space in the stableyard, and possibly in the house, with parts of the House and stables open periodically for public viewing, with some rooms in the House open more regularly or available for public hire, displays etc.

Attached to the Long List are sketches showing how much of the House could be new-build.

The January 2016 Update report

The January 2016 Update Report might better be identified as an interim report, and is perhaps less informative than:

The Report on Options

This Report on Options (actually dated April 2016) considers the objectives and finance of the project and the risks to it. The objectives are set as Restoration, Public Access and Viability. It then focuses on the reduced list of options and shows how they fit with the objectives. The paper goes on to compare the financial profiles of each option. It includes a baseline business model (including a café, rentable space and a degree of heritage interpretation), capital costs, comparative discounted cash flows for the various models, and the runs a risk assessment on them.

It concludes (albeit with a number of caveats) that restoration and part re-build of the House and artist’s studios in the stablyard as enabling development are the preferred solutions.

This paper takes into account the comprehensive Market Context Analysis, which puts Broomfield House in a wider context and develops the concept of the growing potential for creative studio workshop places which it assesses presents an opportunity to capitalise and gain a share of this market.

Finally, the Cost Model covers in detail the refurbishment/rebuild costs for Broomfield House, the stableyard buildings and, four options for their use [3], the demolition of the row of 1960’s houses in the stableyard and should it come to it, for the demolition of Broomfield House itself.

"Soft Marketing"

Using this information, the next steps are for Enfield to beginning informal "soft marketing", seeking expressions of interest from potential commercial partners. Looking further ahead, Enfield and the existing Broomfield House Trust and Friends of Broomfield Park are planning a seminar with Historic England and the Architectural Heritage Fund on a potential management trust for a restored House and Stableyard. It is likely that this seminar, which will be by invitation from LBE will look to a wider participation.

In spite of all this work, unless funding from a commercial partner or partners and further grants from the HLF and others can be agreed, demolition of the House remains a possibility.

Colin Younger
Chair, The Broomfield House Trust

Footnotes

  1. The remit of the Partnership Board is to identify and deliver restoration of Broomfield House, Stable Block and Park to provide maximum access whilst ensuring the building has a viable use for the future. 
  2. For those not familiar with the status of Broomfield House it is a II* listed building on the Historic England list of Heritage at Risk. Historic England (represented on the Board) have advised on the strategy which the Board has been following.
  3. Art Studios, Performance art space, Commercial use/offices, and Residential use.
The remit of the Partnership Board is to identify and deliver restoration of Broomfield House, Stable Block and Park to provide maximum access whilst ensuring the building has a viable use for the future. 

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Broomfield House - latest news

Colin Younger

05 Sep 2016 11:14 #2256

Share share on facebook icon share on twitter icon Share by email

The LBE website now includes the Gazetteer annex to the Conservation Management Plan. This 277 page paper covers every know feature in the Park, including ones which only the faintest signs now exist and which would need further research, including by archaeologists, to understand. There are short notes on description,background, significance and any management action suggested for each item, photographs and location maps. See:
new.enfield.gov.uk/services/planning/heritage-conservation-and-countryside/broomfield-house/planning-information-broomfield-house-gazetteer-with-plans.pdf

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Broomfield House - latest news

Colin Younger

05 Sep 2016 12:45 #2257

Share share on facebook icon share on twitter icon Share by email

Enfield is arranging a seminar to explore future governance/management arrangements for Broomfield House and stableyard should the rebuilding programme go ahead. This is what LBE have said. Please note the section I have marked in bold.


Historic England and Architectural Heritage Fund have indicated the afternoon of 19th October to provide a governance workshop.
We will be requiring attendees to register for the event, which will enable us to retain some control and ensure that the event is restricted to the Trust / Friends and others with genuine skills and commitment to offer the project.
We need to know likely numbers to arrange a suitable venue.

Once I receive confirmation of who is to definitely attend I’ll build an attendance list and book a venue.


Could anyone with the time, skills and interest in the future arrangements, who would like to attend let me know at . It might help LBE if those who want to attend could briefly indicate relevant skills/background.

Colin Younger

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Broomfield House - Governance Workshop

Colin Younger

09 Sep 2016 19:43 #2266

Share share on facebook icon share on twitter icon Share by email

Enfield has now posted details of the Governance workshop at:

new.enfield.gov.uk/services/planning/heritage-conservation-and-countryside/broomfield-house/planning-information-broomfield-house-governance-workshop-invite.pdf

The posting includes the following:-

Community partners have a vital role to play in steering the Broomfield House project. We will be holding a community capacity building Governance Workshop
in October 2016. This workshop will be delivered by officers from Historic England, the Architectural Heritage Fund and Enfield Council.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Broomfield House - latest news

Colin Younger

22 Oct 2016 11:07 #2347

Share share on facebook icon share on twitter icon Share by email

The seminar on future governance arrangements for a reopened Broomfield House held on 19 October provided a great deal of information and advice about the sort of formal arrangements and the range of skills and expertise which might be needed. The Partnership Board will need to consider how to take this forward, but there would clearly be a huge role for volunteers to join any new management trust.
More immediately, the Broomfield House Trust has a collection box in Palmers Green Waitrose under the Community Matters scheme. This is aimed at gaining support for our plan to fund a trial restoration of sections of the Lanscroon Mural which used to grace the main hall and stairs. If you shop there and want to support this initiative please drop your green tokens in to our collection box.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Broomfield House will one day be a Star in Palmers Green

Chrystalla Georgiou

01 Dec 2016 17:48 #2474

Share share on facebook icon share on twitter icon Share by email

The potential restoration of Broomfield House is dragging on snail slow. Its hindrance for restoration could be due to the way ideas are presented to those that could financially help raise Broomfield House from the ashes into a very rewarding and profitable property.

In reality, Broomfield's House has huge potential both to the public and financially for Palmers Green but it seems few have the vision and insight to see it.

The property is in the borough of Enfield just like Capel Manor and Forty Hall but with far better travel links because luckily, there is ideally the Palmers Green Railway Station on Broomfield House doorstep, therefore Enfield Council should try and not be reluctant in getting involve by engaging with the Friends of Broomfield Park to help link Broomfield House with the other two mention properties to providing a more or less similar programmes which will include those good ideas proposed by The Friends of Broomfield House.

Broomfield House will entice people to visit and under take courses who would never travel to Forty Hall or Capel Manor for their courses and events. With acknowledge certificates such as City and Guides for various specialized Arts and Crafts courses and acknowledged certificate Horticultural Courses such as Flower Arranging, landscaping. A cinema for youngest for mid morning viewing on the Weekends will mean the cafeteria always be full.

I certainly love the exciting ideas proposed for the Stable Yards which include an Art/Craft Studios and Kitchen Garden.

Centrally, Broomfield House has the potential to become popular and notable. The public love anything to with Arts and Crafts of quality, they always draw in the crowds and Palmers Green will inevitably become a fashionable artistic area.

I wonder for the sake of progress should the name of Broomfield House be extended to characterise its new fashion potential ? For example Broomfield House of Specialized Course and Events, a name is said to hold much value and promise.

Personally, it shocking that Broomfield House has remained in its current state with hope of it restoration each year never to materialize. Enfield Council must be generating a lot of revenue in the borough to allow this house to remain in it current burned out shell, because one day Broomfield House will be big business and people will wonder why it took so long to restore.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Broomfield House

Catharine Perry

08 Dec 2016 11:02 #2486

Share share on facebook icon share on twitter icon Share by email

This may make me no friends in Palmers Green, but I think one option for Broomfield House would be to knock it down and replace it with a community centre designed for that purpose. We can't keep everything from the past! And what about accessibility? I doubt it's designed for wheelchairs, lifts would have to be put in. "Surviving fragments of 16th century fabric, ... the stair hall and [being] the focal point of a largely intact Baroque and earlier landscape", may not be enough to justify restoration, and a spectacular modern building fit for purpose might in fact be cheaper. The sad scaffolded building has been there for so long that a whizzy bright modern building would soon find a place in people's affections.

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Broomfield House

Garry Humphreys

08 Dec 2016 18:14 #2488

Share share on facebook icon share on twitter icon Share by email

I don't agree with you, but I know exactly what you mean! The disgrace of Broomfield House has been the Council's foot dragging over a period of more than 20 years. When the fires occurred (and I bet they weren't accidental!) the insurance money should have been spent on restoring the building immediately rather than squandering it on years of so-called 'security' provision as the building itself fell into further decay. The whole thing could have been sorted quickly and (certainly at today's prices) relatively cheaply with the building adding lustre to the park and providing an income for the Council. But the opportunist Philistines on the Council had other priorities (largely short term) , often contributing to the downgrading of the streetscape. Have they learned any lessons? Not if the Green Dragon debacle is anything to go by ...

Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.

Moderators: PGC WebmasterBasil Clarke
Time to create page: 0.488 seconds
Powered by Kunena
Clicky