Accessibility Tools

Follow Palmers Green Community on Facebook Follow Palmers Green Community on Twitter Follow Palmers Green Community on Bluesky

Comment

Share this article share on facebook Share on Bluesky share on twitter

In response to criticism, an Arnos Grove councillor insists there is no need for the safer pedestrian crossing near the Piccadilly Line bridge that a now cancelled scheme would have provided. Is he really so blind to the hazards that this crossing poses?

In response to last week's article, Cllr Paul Pratt denies that crossing Waterfall Road near the Piccadilly Line bridge is hazardous: “In many cases, myself included, {drivers] give way to pedestrians”

Last week I published an article criticising Cllr Paul Pratt for rejoicing over the cancellation of a project intended to reduce danger for pedestrians and cyclists negotiating a series of risky road crossings between Palmers Green and Arnos Grove/New Southgate. Cllr Pratt used the forum to respond to some of the points I made (but wrote that he will not be replying to any further articles).

One of the questions I put to him was:

Do you not think that residents of streets of Pymms Green Road and nearby streets deserve a safe way of reaching Arnos Park on foot or by bike? Why then are you rejoicing over the cancellation of the parallel walking and cycling crossing over Waterfall Road that would replace the current uncontrolled crossing with its tiny island where people are marooned while drivers speed by them on either side?

He responded as follows:

Yes. How many pedestrian accidents have there been at the Waterfall Road uncontrolled crossing in the last 5 years? As a driver on this road on an almost daily basis, your suggestion that drivers speed by is inaccurate. They drive by and in many cases, myself included they give way to pedestrians.

Is he suggesting that it is inappropriate to install a pedestrian crossing at locations where no-one has ever been hit by a car within the last five years? Even when from the perspective of a pedestrian or cyclist crossing the road at this point, connecting two well used walking routes, it is obvioua to anyone preparing to do so that this is not a safe crossing point? Does someone have to be injured or killed? And does he seriously think that drivers don't speed by here? (I'm not alleging that they break the speed limit, I'm saying they drive too fast past pedestrians stranded on the narrow island.)

We can discount Cllr Pratt's description of how the crossing looks from a driver's point of view, he will only be there for a few fleeting seconds and won't see what is happening at other times or how things appear from a pedestrian's perspective. Has he ever walked across the road here during times when there is traffic about and tried seeing it from the point of view of an old person who can't walk very fast, or a young child, or someone with a baby buggy and another little kid?

Did Cllr Pratt actually watch the video? If so, did it not seem to him that the woman with the two small children appeared scared, and with good reason? Did he not notice one driver completely ignoring the fact that someone was obviously trying to cross the road? Did he not notice another driver apparently still accelerating towards the clearly visible woman and her children when they were in the middle of the road?

Is he unaware that there is no other safe way to cross Waterfall Road nearby and this unsafe crossing is actually the least bad?

Is he unaware that, having risked crossing here and now in Barnet Council territory, pedestrians and cyclists can continue northwards along the footpath, across Osidge Lane, across Parkside Gardens, through Oak Hill Park and from there into the centre of East Barnet, and every time they encounter a road there is either a Zebra or a lights-controlled crossing to enable them to get to the other side safely and confidently?

Request to Arnos Grove ward residents:

Cllr Pratt has written that in future he will only respond to communications from residents of his ward:

N.B. This is the first time I have ever engaged in my capacity as a Councillor online, I don’t intend on replying any further as I much prefer to concentrate on Ward casework. If Arnos Grove residents need me for anything, they can reach out through the proper channel. That being my Council email address or the Ward Forum.

If any of you are as angry about his dismissal of these concerns as I am, perhaps you could take up this invitation - I live in another ward and only use that crossing occasionally.

Log in to comment

Find us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter

Follow us on Bluesky

Clicky